Dialogue on Rafiul Alam

Said is Not Dead: The Case Against Fancy Dialogue Tags

Mon, 10 Feb 2025 00:00:00 +0000

“I love you,” she gasped. “Really?” he queried. “Yes!” she exclaimed. “But-” he stammered. “No buts,” she interjected.

Stop.

This is bad writing. And it’s bad for a very specific reason: the dialogue tags are working too hard.

The golden rule: “Said” is invisible. Everything else calls attention to itself.

And in 95% of cases, you don’t want readers noticing your dialogue tags-you want them immersed in the conversation.

What Are Dialogue Tags?

Dialogue tags (also called “attributions”) identify who’s speaking:

Silence, Interruption, and Overlap: Realistic Speech Patterns

Sun, 09 Feb 2025 00:00:00 +0000

Perfect turn-taking is a myth.

Real conversations don’t work like written dialogue usually looks:

A: "I went to the store."
B: "What did you buy?"
A: "Milk and bread."

Real conversations are messier:

A: "I went to the store and-"
B: "Did you get the milk?"
A: "I was about to-yeah, I got-"
B: "Because last time you forgot and-"
A: "I got it! I got the milk."

Real speech includes:

The 'No' Game in Dialogue: Characters Who Never Say Yes Directly

Sat, 08 Feb 2025 00:00:00 +0000

Watch any great dialogue scene and you’ll notice something: characters almost never directly agree with each other.

Even when they’re on the same side, even when they ultimately want the same thing, they resist, deflect, challenge, or qualify.

This is called “The No Game”-and it’s one of the simplest, most powerful techniques for creating dynamic dialogue.

What Is the “No” Game?

The principle: Characters instinctively resist what other characters say, even in small ways.

Subtext: What Characters Really Mean - The Conversation Beneath the Conversation

Sat, 14 Dec 2024 00:00:00 +0000

“We should talk.”

Three words. Grammatically simple. Literally: a suggestion to have a conversation.

But everyone who hears them knows: Something bad is about to happen. A breakup. A confrontation. A revelation that will hurt.

How do we know? Because of subtext-the meaning beneath the words, the real message hiding under the literal one.

And it’s arguably the most important skill in dialogue writing.

What Is Subtext?

Text: What is literally said Subtext: What is actually meant

Dialogue as Action: Every Line Should Do Something

Sun, 17 Nov 2024 00:00:00 +0000

Bad dialogue is characters talking at each other, exchanging information the writer needs us to know.

Good dialogue is characters doing things to each other with words.

Dialogue isn’t just communication-it’s action. Every line should move something forward: plot, character dynamics, tension, understanding, or emotion.

If you can cut a line of dialogue without losing anything, it shouldn’t be there.

The “Dialogue as Action” Principle

Traditional writing advice separates:

Action = physical events (fights, chases, building things)
Dialogue = characters talking (conveying information, feelings)

This is wrong.